Posts by Edward Champion

Edward Champion is the Managing Editor of Reluctant Habits.

Five Comedies

I’ll take a page from the Black Market Kidneys playbook and unapologetically pilfer the Gray Lady’s idea. Here are five comedies I would take to a desert island:

Our Hospitality 01.jpg1. Our Hospitality: I’ve had countless arguments with film geeks over whether this great Buster Keaton film can be constituted as a classic. And it really boils down to this: your heart either pumps along to the four ventricles behind this film or it doesn’t. Sherlock, Jr. is certainly Keaton’s technical masterpiece. The General is the Keaton’s photographic masterpiece. But, if I had to pick among the three great Keaton films, it would be this one. If only for the great sequence in which Keaton is trying to keep inside the house to avoid being shot and the dog that follows Keaton across the country.

2. After Hours: This is Scorsese’s comedy masterpiece, a woefully misunderstood film that is nothing less than a Candide-like dissection of America, where connecting with others is hindered by people who are ensnared by their own cultural fixations and violence is sometimes the only way out. Is Griffin Dunne really the normal one? Or does his yuppie contentment trigger the madness around him? I’ve never tired of this film, which can be viewed as a deranged laugh riot or a scathing allegory.

oluckyman.jpg3. O Lucky Man! And while we’re on the subject of Candide, I’d be remiss if I didn’t dig up Lindsay Anderson’s great three-hour epic. I’m not certain if O Lucky Man! qualifies completely as a comedy, but it certainly has many funny and fucked up moments. I’ve yet to meet a single American who has loved this film as much as I have, but I’d certainly count this in the top five.

4. The Rules of the Game: Of course, if you’re on a desert island and you’re on a fish and pineapple diet, Renoir’s indictment of the upper class, showing the utter folly of hubris and manners, is mandatory repeat viewing. That way, in the event that you do get rescued, you can remind yourself how not to be self-indulgent.

5. Monkey Business (1931): This is certainly a funny film featuring the criminally underrated Zeppo Marx. But the reason it’s on this list is for educational purposes. There are valuable lessons here on how to sneak aboard an ocean liner. And such a skill set might come in handy, should you manage to escape the island. (I should note that if there was a sixth choice, the fantastic 1952 film Monkey Business directed by Howard Hawks, entirely unrelated, would most certainly be on here.)

Roundup

BSS #79: Mark Z. Danielewski

segundo79.jpg

Condition of Mr. Segundo: Horrified by “misprinted” books.

Author: Mark Z. Danielewski

Subjects Discussed: The origins of Only Revolutions, Hailey’s appearance in House of Leaves, the use of obscure uncanonized words in Only Revolutions (and their various origins), hip-hop, Gene Wolfe, Anthony Burgess, teenagers and vocabulary, how structure affects wordplay, skateboards, the influence of movies, the dots on the right-hand corner, on whether Danielewski is an experimental writer, fonts and typography, leaving room for ambiguity in a taut structure, the urgency in getting Only Revolutions finalized, the leftwrist twist, how the circular symbol came about, and immortality and maturity.

[PLEASE NOTE: The most enthusiastic answer from an author in Bat Segundo history occurs at 32:49.]

EXCERPT FROM SHOW:

Danielewski: I don’t think I’m an experimental writer. I don’t really know what that means, in fact, an experimental writer. For me, it’s always an exploration. I just can’t help but think, you know, when you experiment, you’re kind of tinkering. And this is such a prolonged investigation. You don’t tinker for six years. It’s a long quest to see where something goes. And the thing I really stand by is that I’ve fulfilled the qualities of Sam and Hailey’s journey. Now whether it’s a success or not, it’s clear what it is. It’s not halfly done. It’s wholly, spinningly done. You can either say, I don’t care for it. Or you can recognize, wow, if we go, if we follow this path to its — maybe not its conclusion, but as a long way, this is kind of where it ends up going. And these are the things you get out of it. And these are things you don’t get out of it. And that creates a valid type of conversation.

BSS #78: Richard Dawkins

segundo78.jpg

Condition of Mr. Segundo: Attempting to set up a tequila-faith based organization.

Author: Richard Dawkins

Subjects Discussed: The audience for The God Delusion, comparing an atheistic text to Satan, evolutionary biology and religion, charitable religious-based organizations, Mother Teresa, whether imaginary constructs are a bad thing, living in the real world, the assassination of Harvey Milk, Twinkies, “In God We Trust” and the American zeitgeist, on Dawkins being “a university person” speaking to university crowds, politics and atheism, Stephen Jay Gould and non-overlapping magisteria, language and religion, Marilynne Robinson’s review, logical positivism, love and perception, sexual lust, on deists being fools, the susceptibility of children, the advertising industry vs. religion, Jesus Camp, and extremists vs. everyday religious people.

EXCERPT FROM SHOW:

Correspondent: What of love? You kind of go into this a little bit into the book. For example, speaking personally for myself, I’m madly in love with my girlfriend right now. But could I tell you — is there any sort of rational basis for this? No, not really. Would I do a lot for her? Well, absolutely. I would do all inexplicable sorts of things, that are completely irrational, for her.

Dawkins: Well, I’m delighted to hear that. I wouldn’t call them completely irrational. If you’re asking, how does either of you know that you love the other, then that is rational. I mean, that’s based upon evidence, that’s based upon little looks, smiles, catches in the voice, things you do for each other. That’s all evidence. Just because it’s subtle and complicated doesn’t make it free from evidence. It is evidence based. Of course, it could be wrong. But that’s always true of evidence-based belief.