Gregory McDonald Dead

Giles News is reporting that Gregory McDonald, the tremendously talented author of the Fletch series has died. I am now making efforts to confirm this. If this is true, this is a tremendous loss to American letters.

[UPDATE: I have confirmed by phone with Charlie of the Giles County Ambulance Service that Gregory McDonald passed away on Sunday. As soon as I have a chance to collect my thoughts and feelings, I plan to offer a full-length tribute here. I’m still in shock.]

I first encountered the Fletch books in the library when I was twelve. The ratty paperbacks were bound in taut cellophane. I didn’t understand why they hadn’t been released in hardcover. But as it turned out, there were complex reasons. I had, of course, known about the Chevy Chase movie. But Chase’s wisecracks (as conveyed through Andrew Bergman’s screenplay) weren’t even close to McDonald’s great barbs. The first Fletch book was driven almost entirely by dialogue, keeping up a momentum that sucked me into the text. The story goes that mystery purists were upset that McDonald published the Fletch books as paperback originals. They were also angered that McDonald had used sex and wit to draw readers into his novels. But McDonald wanted ordinary people to read them. McDonald’s Fletch books, however, were far from ordinary.

Here’s the first page from Fletch:

“What’s your name?”

“Fletch.”

“What’s your full name?”

“Fletcher.”

“What’s your first name?”

“Irwin.”

“What?”

“Irwin. Irwin Fletcher. People call me Fletch.”

“Irwin Fletcher, I have a proposition to make to you. I will give you a thousand dollars for just listening to it. If you decide to reject the proposition, you take the thousand dollars, go away, and never tell anyone we talked. Fair enough?”

“Is it criminal? I mean, what you want me to do?”

“Of course.”

“Fair enough. For a thousand bucks I can listen. What do you want me to do?”

“I want you to murder me.”

The black shoes tainted with sand came across the oriental rug. The man took an envelope from an inside pocket of his suit jacket and dropped it into Fletch’s lap. Inside were ten one-hundred-dollar bills.

Now what sane person wouldn’t want to continue reading this story? This opening is as gripping as the first page of James M. Cain’s The Postman Always Rings Twice often taught in literature classes, but it likewise carries a concern for precision reminiscent of Tom Stoppard’s Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead. McDonald stubbornly resists description until the very end. He lets his characters convey the specifics through dialogue. We learn that Fletch is a casual sort who can’t abide fussy types using proper names. We learn immediately that he’s sharp, that he’s not going to permit himself to get caught up in illegal activity without considering all the details. We learn that the mysterious interlocutor is more concerned with specifics rather than logistics.

And then there’s that magnificent amateur quality juxtaposed against this questioner’s wealth. The sandy shoes indicate that this mysterious questioner probably isn’t what you might call experienced. But he does have a lot of money.

McDonald was able to set this very careful relationship, along with its many nuances, in a mere 138 words. And he was able to do this almost entirely through dialogue. He was an extraordinary writer. And what made him so extraordinary was his ability to merge this concern for detail with a tremendous ear for dialogue, down to the comma, producing books that could be enjoyed and appreciated by both popular and literary audiences. (A telling indicator of his mass appeal is that filmmaker Kevin Smith learned to write dialogue by reading the Fletch books. Smith snatched up all the movie rights to the Fletch series many years ago, but movies have yet to appear.)

But because McDonald insisted that ordinary readers were capable of basic intelligence, because he insisted that his books should be priced affordably, he was not taken as seriously as he deserved by the old guard. Fletch, nevertheless, would go on to win an Edgar Award for Best Novel. And the book’s sequel, Confess, Fletch, would win for Best Paperback Original.

By all accounts, McDonald was a private person. But Vintage Crime reissued all of the Fletch books a few years ago. And the work will live on.

RELATED: Thankfully, Don Swaim talked with McDonald twice. From the 1987 interview:

MCDONALD: There is a very exciting thing going on in this country. And that is that there have begun to be small publishers in places like Boston, Atlanta, San Francisco, Los Angeles, wherever. And they are not doing what the big commercial houses are doing, of trying to publish the imitation of last year’s imitation of last year’s imitation. And I’m sorry that I can’t cite you chapter and verse. But I am finding that these small publishing houses are creating or letting be published for the first time in a long time in American history and American literature, and they are publishing very exciting stuff, very real stuff, very original stuff, and taking the risks that the big commercial houses wouldn’t do. And they are nurturing the work, and they are nurturing the writers in a way that the big commercial houses don’t do. And I don’t mind at all throwing my lot in with them.

[UPDATE: Mere hours after this post went up, The Rap Sheet’s Cameron Hughes offered his “tribute,” seeing fit to use the same excerpt, similar phrasings, and similar examples from this post. Gee, thanks a lot, assholes.]

© 2008, Edward Champion. All rights reserved.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

12 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Leonard T. Carruthers
Leonard T. Carruthers
17 years ago

Followed the link here from Ms. Weinman’s blog. That is truely sad news. I remember reading one of the Fletch books on the train years ago and trying not to giggle like a fool. People must have thought I was mad. My firm handled a couple plagiarism cases—that’s a serious charge. I read over the pieces and noted some obvious similarities: You’re both writing about the death of Gregory McDonald; you both quote the first page of dialogue from Fletch. Other than that I don’t see any overt borrowings much less anything rising to the level of theft. The pieces read like 2 appreciations from 2 fans coming from similar places of admiration. That’s a natural piece of dialogue to quote as it’s probably the most famous thing that author ever wrote—wasn’t it included on the front cover of the paperback? I had a law review article (of all things) plagiarised once so I can see why you’d be frustrated. But I think perhaps you owe Mr. Hughes an apology. Both of these are warm tributes and should stand without the acrimony. Accusing others of being “assholes” on a page celebrating the life of such a treasured writer is simply crass.

tuck
tuck
17 years ago

well put, Ed. Though I can only pray Kevin Smith never gets around to making those Fletch movies, as he (Smith) is about as hard-edged as a ball of cotton candy, and despite their comedy, the Fletch books do have some serious grit to them…

J. Kingston Pierce
17 years ago

This example of schoolyard fisticuffs has really hit the point of ridiculousness. Therefore, I shall post here the same note I sent to Mr. Champion this morning:

“Cameron Hughes is a young writer who felt intimidated by your accusations. If he felt any need to “apologize” for having used the same obvious excerpt that you did, it was because of that inexperience. The fact that his feelings about Mcdonald’s demise are similar to your own is hardly surprising. If he was inspired by your write-up, it is hardly grounds for declaring war on The Rap Sheet or anybody associated with demonstrates pettiness of your part, not dishonor on his. I do not find the similarities condemning, nor all that obvious.

“I am sorry that your feelings are hurt, but I believe you are blowing this WAY out of proportion. There are numerous more important things to address in this world than whether another writer has the same sympathies as you do.
We have all felt at one point or another that somebody else has trod upon the same journalistic path as we have. The mature thing is to recognize its insignificance in the scheme of things, and move on.”

J. Kingston Pierce
Editor, The Rap Sheet

Patrick Stephenson
Patrick Stephenson
17 years ago

Anyway.

There’s a Fletch book in my car that I bought a few weeks ago and haven’t yet read. Based on *this* post, it’ll definitely get read soon.

Cameron Hughes
Cameron Hughes
17 years ago

Hold on, I admitted to copying the excerpt which you do not own nor do you have domain over it because you used it first. I copied nothing else, and last I checked, similar phrasing, intentional or not isn’t un-ethical and is employed in millions of College essays everyday.

That is not plagiarism. Your claims are silly. You say he accomplished a lot in a mere 138 words, I talk about how much he accomplished in a very short novel that most twice that length would not. And in case I am mistaken, when I say 1940’s screwball comedies, that has nothing to do with The Postman rings twice. Nor do I see what Gilmore Girls has to do with a play concerning two minor characters from a Shakespeare play.

Rod Lott
Rod Lott
17 years ago

That’s not plagiarism. If anything, paraphrasing would be a more accurate description, but even then, I don’t think they’re that similar, other than quoting the same page. To be honest, if I were writing a tribute, that’d be the part I’d quote, too, as it was my first exposure to McDonald, and the one that’s always stuck with me.

J. Kingston Pierce
17 years ago

I won’t engage with people of your temper. Only level-headed people can have level-headed discussions. You have passed the line. I invite you to argue with yourself.

Cheers,
Jeff

trackback
17 years ago

[…] McDonald, author of the Fletch series, has […]

trackback

[…] genius who inspired this musical montage has passed. Ed has a nice eulogy for Gregory McDonald, and it’s especially nice since it ends with the word […]